« K-16--Focus | Main | Everybody Needs 2 »

The Have-Nots versus the Have-Nothings

The aftermath of Hurricane Katrina has recently sucked up most of my mental and physical energy. As a Houstonian, I am truly proud of the generous response that our city has had for the evacuees. Our local city and county officials have been able to organize the enormous relief efforts that the federal officials were either too incompetent or too timid to render. An amazing coalition of businesses, civic groups, faith-based communities, and individuals has come together to care for our new neighbors. On a personal note, I am volunteering a few hours a week at a small church-based shelter, and I am part of a team that will provide meals for the residents of that shelter until everyone finds a new home.

When I get past my awe of nature's power and my anger at the inadequate, unorganized rescue efforts, I am most intrigued by how this situation is impacting our schools. 3403 evacuated students have enrolled in Houston ISD schools, and over 15,000 are in the greater Houston area. At last week's portfolio group meeting, Michaelann mentioned that she had a few new students in her art classes and that she could sense some resentment brewing. Her concern was that she and her students had worked hard on building community by setting norms together and engaging in regular teambuilding activities: How could she smoothly bring the newcomers into the classroom community? I thought, "Oh my goodness, if somebody as skillful as Michaelann is at building learning communities is worried about this--just imagine what most teachers are facing as they integrate a huge new population into their classes!"

Sure enough, today's Houston Chronicle reported this story--"Tensions overflow at Jones High School: 5 teens sent to jail after fight erupts between local students and evacuees."

The newspaper reported that 200 hurricane survivors are bused daily from the Reliant Park shelters to Jones. The fight erupted when some students from New Orleans "started threatening to take over the campus and the city." A Houston student threw an open Sprite can at a new student's head and about 25 students were involved in the brawl that sent 3 kids to the hospital for injuries to the face and ribs.

Here are the quotes that I found most interesting,
Teens said they're frustrated that the evacuees are getting extra asistance and special attention.
"Nobody's giving us $2,000. When it floods here, we don't go over there," said Pedro Umana, 14, a freshman from Houston.

Robert Muhammad, southwest regional minister of the Nation of Islam, said leaders must address the concersns of Houston students. . . . "We must address these legitimate complaints of our children. We can't sweep this under the rug," he said. "Those who have always been the least, the lost in this city would feel somewhat neglected."

HISD school board member Arthur Gaines said educators may have been so focused on finding schools for Louisiana students to attend that they didn't spend enough time making sure the children would get along.
"I don't think we should have just assumed these youngsters were going to melt in because they were black," Gaines said. "I think if the staff and teachers had worked with the students to say: 'Look, they've lost their homes. They've lost everything. . . . I want you to put your arms around them.'"

Questions this raises for me
What can I do to address the long-term, generational poverty in Houston?
What kinds of resources (not just money) would it take to wipe out poverty or will the poor always be with us?
When will policymakers realize that developing skills in building relationships is important in schooling?

Comments (3)

Michaelann:

I think I have been successful in bringing some of my students into the classroom culture and melding them with the old. I still have some troubles and it is not them not getting along -- the one little girl is just so traumatized that she can't or won't open up to anyone at this point.

On the other hand -- I don't want to get into a political debate -- but I think there is enough blame to go around and the cycle of poverty that is/was present was nutured by the current local and state governments as well.

Donna:

Michaelann,
I laughed at your comment "I don't want to get into a political debate" because I think that we're going to have to get more political in order to adequately address the issues that are so dear to us. I'm really sick of having people in office (both major parties and all levels of government) that are more interested in ruling than governing.

Michaelann:

I meant with you -- as friends.

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on September 14, 2005 10:54 PM.

The previous post in this blog was K-16--Focus.

The next post in this blog is Everybody Needs 2.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33